MIDAS products

Home / Guides / Compare roofing quotes

Bid Decision Kit · free guide

How to compare roofing quotes line by line

Roof replacement quotes are hard to compare because each roofer lists different things, and the cheapest total often leaves something out. Line the quotes up on the same rows first, then compare totals. This is a checklist for asking questions, not roofing, engineering, legal, or contracting advice. It does not recommend a contractor and it does not verify licenses or insurance; check those with your state or local authority.

The rows to line up

RowWhat to ask each roofer to state in writing
Tear-off or overlayWill existing layers be removed? How many layers are assumed? Is disposal (dumpster, haul-away) included?
Decking (roof sheathing)How much damaged decking is included in the price, and what is the per-sheet price beyond that? This is a common place for totals to grow after tear-off.
Underlayment and ice barrierWhich underlayment, and where (if anywhere) a self-adhered ice-and-water membrane goes.
Shingles or roofing materialManufacturer and product line, color, and the number of squares (1 square = 100 sq ft) the quote assumes.
Flashing and drip edgeReplaced or reused? Chimney, walls, skylights, valleys.
VentilationRidge vents, box vents, intake: what changes, if anything.
Permit and inspectionWho pulls the permit, and is the fee in the price?
CleanupNail sweep, landscaping protection, gutter cleanout.
WarrantyWorkmanship warranty (from the roofer, how many years) is separate from the material warranty (from the manufacturer). Get both in writing.
TimelineStart window, expected days on site, weather delays.
Payment scheduleDeposit amount, what triggers each payment, and the final payment after completion. Do the payments add up to the quoted price?
Change ordersHow extra work is priced and approved before it is done.

Turning the rows into a comparable total

  1. Where a quote is silent on a row, mark it as a gap rather than a saving.
  2. Fill each gap with a figure you can defend: the other roofer’s line for the same item, or a number you asked for. Label it as your figure.
  3. Add a contingency for the decking unknown that you choose yourself (for example, the per-sheet price times the number of sheets you think is plausible).
  4. Only now compare totals. A quote that is $1,500 lower but excludes decking and disposal may not be lower at all.

Fictional example

Quote A: $14,200, includes tear-off of one layer, disposal, 3 sheets of decking, then $95 per sheet. Quote B: $12,900, silent on disposal, decking “as needed at $110 per sheet”. If you assume 10 sheets: A = 14,200 + 7 × 95 = $14,865. B = 12,900 + 10 × 110 + a $600 disposal figure you obtained = $14,600. Closer than the headline $1,300 gap, and the decision now turns on warranty and payment terms, not just price.

Do it in the free tool

The free Bid Decision Kit comparison tool lines up two bids offline in your browser, flags missing scope and payment terms, and computes a comparable total from figures you type (tool overview; no email needed). The paid Bid Decision Kit ($29) adds a third bid and a companion workbook. Local-tested; not market-validated. For any trade, see the general guide: how to compare contractor bids line by line.

No Buy button? Checkout is switched off right now, or JavaScript is blocked in this browser. The product page has the details.

More guides: the guides hub. All products: Tallyfox hub. Privacy: site privacy notice.