Home / Guides / Compare contractor bids
Bid Decision Kit · free guide
How to compare contractor bids line by line
The usual mistake is to compare only the bottom-line total. Public consumer guidance, including California’s Contractors State License Board, tells buyers to get more than one written bid and to compare them on the same scope — and not to treat the lowest number as automatically best. This page is decision-support, not engineering, legal, or contracting advice. It does not recommend a contractor and it does not verify licenses.
A practical sequence
- Write the scope once, in your words, and give every bidder the same list.
- Ask for written bids that separate labor, materials, allowances, permits, cleanup, exclusions, timeline, warranty, and payment schedule.
- Line the bids up on those rows, not on the total. If a row is blank, that is a flag, not a savings.
- Add your own numbers for missing items (a bid from another contractor, or a supplier quote, or a figure you typed yourself and labeled as yours — label it as your figure).
- Look at the adjusted comparable total only after the rows match or the gaps are flagged.
- Log whether you were shown a license, insurance, references, warranty, and payment terms. Looking them up yourself on a state board is still your task; a worksheet is not a verification.
Consumer write-ups in 2026 still emphasize allowances (what happens if the fixture costs more), who pulls the permit, and payment tied to finished work rather than a large unpaid deposit. Treat those as questions to ask, not as rules this site is enforcing.
Do the lining-up in the free 2-bid tool
The free Bid Decision Kit comparison tool is an offline HTML worksheet for exactly two bids. The Bid Decision Kit page explains the tool and has an optional email list. It computes a comparable true-cost range from amounts you type, including a change-order risk percent you choose (it never applies a “typical industry” default as if it were a fact). A fictional kitchen-remodel example is included for practice.
Optional email
You can use the tool without giving an email address. If you want a note if a fuller paid kit is later offered, you can join the list on the tool page after a comparison is on screen, or here:
Related: guides hub. Privacy: privacy notice.